Top Instagram Ads Agencies in NYC: Who Really Delivers Results

Instagram remains one of the most powerful platforms for brands, especially in a fast-paced city like New York where visual storytelling and quick trends can make or break visibility. With billions of daily users scrolling through feeds packed with content, simply posting organic content often isn't enough anymore. Top agencies in NYC focus on paid Instagram advertising-crafting eye-catching creatives, nailing precise audience targeting, and optimizing campaigns in real time to drive traffic, leads, and sales. These firms understand the platform's algorithm shifts, Meta's ad tools, and what resonates with diverse New York audiences, from fashion-forward millennials in Manhattan to niche communities in Brooklyn.

The best ones combine creative flair with data-driven strategy. They handle everything from carousel ads and Reels promotions to Stories takeovers and shoppable posts, often layering in influencer partnerships or user-generated content for authenticity. What sets the leading players apart is their track record: consistent ROAS improvements, lower cost-per-clicks, and campaigns that scale without wasting budgets. In a market full of options, the standout agencies prioritize measurable outcomes over flashy promises, helping businesses cut through the noise and actually see growth from their Instagram efforts.

Double Your ROAS: Extuitive Predictive Modeling Revolutionizes Instagram Ads

In the high-stakes NYC Instagram marketing landscape, we believe the traditional "trial and error" model is fundamentally broken. At Extuitive, we provide a predictive AI tool that serves as a high-tech alternative to agencies that still rely on guessing with your budget. We have replaced the outdated "spend to learn" approach with a robust predictive advertising framework, designed to evaluate the potential of every creative asset before a single dollar is spent on media.

By leveraging our proprietary polyintelligence and predictive modeling, we synthesize your brand’s unique historical data with large-scale consumer behavioral patterns. Our predictive engine classifies each ad by its expected performance level, allowing brands to immediately filter out weak content and concentrate 100% of their budget on high-confidence winners. We use predictive analytics to forecast CTR and ROAS, transforming Instagram advertising into a precision-engineered, scalable system. At Extuitive, we ensure every launch is backed by predictive data, making growth a predictable outcome rather than a series of expensive experiments.

Instagram Ads in NYC – Agencies That Move the Needle

1. inBeat

inBeat centers its approach around creators and the content they produce naturally, then scales that across different formats and paid channels. Performance data guides every step, from deciding what creative gets made to how media budgets get allocated. Decisions stay tied to what actually stops scrolls, drives clicks, and leads to conversions. They manage paid media programs that include social platforms, balancing spend based on validated creative and positioning.

Key Highlights:

• Starts with creator-led content that scales to paid
• Tracks performance signals across creative and media
• Ships hundreds of assets monthly for iteration
• Focuses on full-funnel strategies involving paid and creators
• Manages significant paid media volume

Services:

• Influencer marketing
• Always-on UGC
• B2B paid social
• Performance creative production
• Growth strategy and consulting
• Media buying and attribution

Contact Information:

• Website: inbeat.agency
• Phone: (917) 243-9205
• Email: hello@inbeat.agency
• Address: 90 Broad St 2nd Floor, New York, NY 10004, United States
• LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/company/inbeat-agency
• Instagram: www.instagram.com/inbeatco

2. Socialfly

Socialfly operates out of New York and handles a range of digital marketing pieces, with a strong emphasis on social platforms. Paid media campaigns run across channels, aiming for effective reach and returns through targeted execution. Social media management covers Instagram along with other apps, using custom visuals and video plus community tactics to build engagement. Influencer work focuses on aligning campaigns with brand goals for authentic promotion.

Key Highlights:

• Female-founded with a focus on resonant communication
• Handles creative production alongside paid efforts
• Works with brands on full-funnel paid media
• Emphasizes thumb-stopping content for platforms
• Builds strategies that convert viewers to advocates

Services:

• Paid media management
• Social media management
• Influencer marketing
• Creative production
• Strategic development

Contact Information:

• Website: socialflyny.com
• Phone: 917 300 8298
• Email: info@socialflyny.com
• Address: 231 West 29th St - Suite 702, New York NY 10001
• LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/company/socialfly
• Facebook: www.facebook.com/Socialfly
• Twitter: x.com/socialfly
• Instagram: www.instagram.com/socialfly

3. NoGood

NoGood sets up squads tailored to specific growth issues, pulling in performance, content, and creative skills along with their own analytics tools. Social ads get designed to catch attention in feeds, using data-rooted experiences that target scrolling audiences. The approach experiments heavily to refine what works across platforms. Many of their clients see quick revenue jumps once strategies lock in.

Key Highlights:

• Builds purpose-built teams for client challenges
• Uses proprietary analytics and AI in campaigns
• Focuses on thumb-stopping social media experiences
• Works with startups through to larger brands
• High client retention from consistent results

Services:

• Social ads
• Paid search
• SEO
• Performance branding
• Organic social
• AEO

Contact Information:

• Website: nogood.io
• LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/company/nogood
• Facebook: www.facebook.com/nogood.io
• Instagram: www.instagram.com/nogood.io

4. Thrive Agency

Thrive Agency shows up in broader digital marketing discussions, though their main base sits outside NYC. They run paid advertising that includes social channels, often layering in targeted campaigns for measurable lifts in leads or sales. Results examples point to big ROAS jumps in some cases, but specifics on Instagram-only work stay lighter compared to pure social shops.

Key Highlights:

• Combines strategy with execution for growth
• Tracks performance across multiple channels
• Delivers qualified leads through paid efforts
• Offers audits that spot opportunities in ads

Services:

• Paid advertising
• Paid social
• Conversion rate optimization
• SEO
• Email marketing
• Content marketing

Contact Information:

• Website: thriveagency.com   
• Phone: (315) 930-1001
• Address: 260 Madison Ave, 8th Floor, Manhattan, NY 10016
• LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/company/thrive-agency
• Facebook: www.facebook.com/ThriveAgency
• Twitter: x.com/ThriveAgency
• Instagram: www.instagram.com/thriveinternetmarketingagency

5. Lilo Social

Lilo Social brings together data-driven decisions with creative work across the customer journey, handling acquisition through targeted campaigns on search and social platforms. Creative optimization plays a big role in their approach, paired with transparent reporting that tracks engagement and ROI. Retention efforts lean into email and SMS for loyalty building, while on-demand creative delivers visuals and stories shaped by performance data. Paid media gets mentioned in their tracked revenue impact, though specifics stay broad.

Key Highlights:

• Focuses on full-funnel from acquisition to retention
• Uses creative optimization in campaigns
• Tracks attributed revenue through paid and retention
• Delivers data-driven visuals and narratives
• Emphasizes transparent reporting

Services:

• Full-funnel growth
• Retention via email and SMS
• Creative on demand
• Targeted campaigns on search and social

Contact Information:

• Website: lilosocial.com
• Phone: (347) 619-3312 
• Email: hello@lilosocial.com
• Address: 300 Cadman Plaza West, 12th Floor, Brooklyn, NY 11201
• LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/company/lilosocial
• Instagram: www.instagram.com/lilosocial

6. Atomic Social

Atomic Social runs social media ads on platforms like Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, LinkedIn, and YouTube with hyper-targeted creative. Ads get crafted to drive traffic, leads, and sales, often paired with landing pages built for conversions. The approach integrates customer insights for targeting. Other pieces like web design and Google Ads support the overall digital presence, though social ads form a core offering for engagement and results.

Key Highlights:

• Targets ads on Instagram and other social
• Builds creative for conversions
• Uses customer insights in targeting
• Combines ads with landing pages
• Operates as a boutique agency

Services:

• Social media ads
• Google Ads
• Web design
• SEO
• Content marketing
• Graphic design

Contact Information:

• Website: atomicsocial.com
• Phone: (602) 490-3252
• Address: 7949 E Acoma Dr, Scottsdale, AZ 85260
• LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/company/atomicsocial
• Facebook: www.facebook.com/AtomicSocialCo
• Twitter: x.com/AtomicSociaI
• Instagram: www.instagram.com/atomicsocial

7. AdVenture PPC

AdVenture combines performance advertising minds with AI tools to run campaigns across Google, Meta, and other channels. Meta ads management covers Facebook and Instagram, using custom audiences, rich media, and messaging for results. Offices sit in Woodmere, NY (close to NYC), plus spots in Philadelphia and Florida. Case studies highlight strong ROAS on Facebook, with one brand hitting high multiples through social efforts. The focus stays on profit-driven execution.

Key Highlights:

• Runs Meta ads including Instagram
• Has a New York office in Woodmere
• Delivers high ROAS in case studies
• Uses AI alongside strategists
• Commits to client profit metrics

Services:

• Meta ads management
• Google ads
• Conversion rate optimization
• Training and consulting

Contact Information:

• Website: www.adventureppc.com
• Phone: (516) 218-3722
• Email: info@adventureppc.com
• Address: 1074 Broadway, Woodmere, NY
• LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/company/adventure-media-group-llc
• Instagram: www.instagram.com/adventureppc

8. Spray Marketing

Spray Marketing acts as a direct-to-expert growth setup, bridging strategy, product, and creative for execution based on data. Digital media builds tailored acquisition roadmaps with optimizations and iterations across channels. Paid social gets included in strategies that coordinate for ROI, though platform details stay general. Creative work produces assets like ads through testing and proven methods. A/B testing runs on nearly everything to refine results. They integrate closely with client teams without extra layers.

Key Highlights:

• Builds custom teams for specific goals
• Handles paid search and social
• Optimizes full user journeys
• Designs direct response creative
• Runs extensive A/B testing
• Focuses on transparent execution

Services:

• Digital media acquisition
• Email marketing and SMS
• Creative shop for ads and assets
• Paid search and social strategy
• Linear advertising and offline

Contact Information:

• Website: www.spray.marketing
• Address: 61 Greenpoint Ave, Brooklyn, New York
• LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/company/spraymarketingllc
• Instagram: www.instagram.com/spray.marketing

9. Power Digital

Power Digital runs digital marketing with a mix of data, tech, and creative input to shape campaigns across channels. Paid social sits as one of their offerings, covering platforms where ads run to drive results. The setup includes strategic consulting plus execution on things like social media, though Instagram specifics stay general. They emphasize transparency in tracking impact and optimizing spend.

Key Highlights:

• Integrates data intelligence with channel work
• Handles paid social alongside other digital areas
• Focuses on measurable business outcomes
• Offers creative and strategy layers
• Builds on performance insights for campaigns

Services:

• Paid social
• SEO
• CRO
• Email and SMS
• Content marketing
• Influencer marketing
• Strategic consulting

Contact Information:

• Website: powerdigitalmarketing.com
• Address: 407 Broome St, New York, NY 10013

10. NinjaPromo

NinjaPromo structures services around a subscription model that bundles various marketing tasks under one monthly fee. PPC gets included for paid efforts, and ads creation falls within the scope for quick turnaround on projects. The approach covers multiple channels with a cross-functional setup, allowing shifts in focus as needs change. Social media ties in through general marketing output, though platform details remain broad.

Key Highlights:

• Uses subscription for on-demand specialists
• Delivers fast project launches
• Covers PPC and ad creation
• Simplifies management across channels
• Aims for unified strategies

Services:

• PPC
• SEO
• Content
• Design
• Ads creation
• Social media elements

Contact Information:

• Website: ninjapromo.io
• Phone: +1 929-492-4413
• Email: hello@ninjapromo.io
• Address: 276 5th Avenue, NY 10001, New York, United States of America
• LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/company/ninjapromo
• Facebook: www.facebook.com/ninjapromoofficial
• Twitter: x.com/ninjapromoio
• Instagram: www.instagram.com/ninja.promo

11. The Influencer Marketing Factory

The Influencer Marketing Factory handles influencer campaigns from start to finish, setting KPIs and matching brands with creators. Social media campaigns run on Instagram along with TikTok and YouTube, focusing on authentic content that scales. The process includes audience targeting, content concepts, contracting, and result tracking with tools for metrics. Paid amplification doesn't get direct mention, but campaigns aim for ROI through engagement and reach.

Key Highlights:

• Covers full influencer campaign management
• Creates campaigns specifically for Instagram
• Defines target personas and goals
• Tracks results with pixels and reporting
• Builds scalable social influencer work

Services:

• Influencer identification and contracting
• Social media campaigns on Instagram
• Target audience definition
• Content creation guidance
• KPI setting and tracking

Contact Information:

• Website: theinfluencermarketingfactory.com
• Phone: (800) 469-9753
• Email: hello@theinfluencermarketingfactory.com
• Address: 66 West Flagler Street – Suite 900 – #1178, Miami, FL 33130
• LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/company/the-influencer-marketing-factory
• Facebook: www.facebook.com/influencermarketingfactory
• Instagram: www.instagram.com/influencermarketingfactory

12. Whalar

Whalar focuses on creator partnerships to shape brand presence through social channels. Campaigns unlock creator content for cultural relevance, with paid amplification strategies that include execution and optimization. The work emphasizes measurable impact from creator-led paid media. Client feedback highlights strong alignment on platforms like TikTok, though Instagram fits into the broader social scope.

Key Highlights:

• Specializes in creator and social agency work
• Offers paid amplification for campaigns
• Turns insights into captivating content
• Builds long-term creator relationships
• Tracks ROI from creator contributions

Services:

• Paid amplification strategy and execution
• Creator sourcing and content production
• Campaign management
• Co-creation for cultural relevance

Contact Information:

• Website: www.whalar.com
• Email: hello@whalar.com
• LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/company/whalar
• Facebook: www.facebook.com/whalar
• Twitter: x.com/whalar
• Instagram: www.instagram.com/whalar

13. Darkroom Agency

Darkroom Agency manages paid media with a focus on profitability first, then scaling brand awareness across social platforms. Paid social forms the baseline, with adjustments for channel-specific strategies and bidding when search or other networks join in. Performance creative gets produced through AI-supported services for ads, graphics, and video editing. Retention marketing covers the full customer journey via CRM, email, and SMS. The approach extends to social commerce for community and discovery-driven growth.

Key Highlights:

• Prioritizes profitability in paid media
• Produces AI creative for ads and assets
• Handles retention across email and SMS
• Manages social commerce strategies
• Tracks attributable revenue from campaigns

Services:

• Paid media management
• Performance creative
• Retention marketing
• TikTok Shop management
• Amazon Marketplace management
• Website optimization

Contact Information:

• Website: www.darkroomagency.com
• Phone: (347) 343-3647
• LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/company/darkroomagency
• Twitter: x.com/darkroomagency_
• Instagram: www.instagram.com/darkroomagency

14. M+C Saatchi Performance

M+C Saatchi Performance plans and buys media across digital channels, including paid social for audience action. Paid search and social sit alongside programmatic, influencer, streaming, and affiliate efforts. Measurement drives optimization, with testing focused on what's actually moving performance. App marketing remains a specialty, though broader channel work covers Instagram through paid social. The setup leans on data and tech for ROI maximization.

Key Highlights:

• Covers paid social in media buying
• Optimizes based on performance testing
• Includes influencer and affiliate channels
• Specializes in app-related marketing
• Tracks ROI through measurement tools

Services:

• Paid social
• Paid search
• Programmatic advertising
• Influencer marketing
• Affiliate marketing
• Data analytics and tech

Contact Information:

• Website: www.mcsaatchiperformance.com
• Email: us@mcsaatchiperformance.com
• Address: 16 West 22nd St, 9th Floor, New York, NY 10010
• LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/company/m-c-saatchi-performance
• Twitter: x.com/MCSaatchiPerf
• Instagram: www.instagram.com/mc_saatchi_performance

Conclusion

Wrapping this up, picking an Instagram ads agency in NYC really comes down to what your business actually needs right now – and what you're willing to put up with in the process. Some shops crush it on creative that stops the scroll and turns heads, others live and breathe data to squeeze every last drop of ROAS, and a few just know the city's weird mix of audiences so well that their targeting feels almost unfair. The thing is, no single agency is going to be perfect for every brand, every budget, or every stage of growth. I've seen founders burn through months (and serious cash) chasing the "best" one only to realize the fit mattered way more than the hype.

So do your homework – dig into case studies that actually look like your product or customer, ask hard questions about how they measure success beyond vanity metrics, and maybe even run a small test campaign with two or three shortlisted options if you can swing it. Instagram moves fast, the algorithm doesn't care about your feelings, and the agencies that stick around in NYC tend to be the ones who adapt quicker than the rest. Find the partner who gets your headaches, communicates like a normal human, and actually moves the needle on revenue instead of just likes. Once you land that, the rest starts feeling a lot less like gambling and a lot more like smart business. Good luck out there – the feed is noisy, but the right help makes cutting through it way easier.

‍